Skip to content
To ensure delivery of the best quality cheese during warm weather, orders will ship UPS Next Day Air.
Home
Creamery Products
See More
Curds
Cheddar
More Cheese
Milk
All Creamery Dairy
Gift Card
Gift Boxes
See More
Cheese Only
Cheese & Meat
All Gift Boxes
Corporate Gifting
Create Your Own
Shop More
See More
Accompaniments
Clothing
Kitchenware
Merch
New Items
Our Other Favorite Cheeses
See All
Visit Us
See More
Directions
Kitchen Menu
Ice Cream Menu
Store Hours
About Us
Log in
Create account
Search
Shopping Cart
0
0
Cart
(
0
)
Home
Creamery Products
Curds
Cheddar
More Cheese
Milk
All Creamery Dairy
Gift Card
Gift Boxes
Cheese Only
Cheese & Meat
All Gift Boxes
Corporate Gifting
Create Your Own
Shop More
Accompaniments
Clothing
Kitchenware
Merch
New Items
Our Other Favorite Cheeses
See All
Visit Us
Directions
Kitchen Menu
Ice Cream Menu
Store Hours
About Us
Loading more
.
.
.
Your own gift box
Build your own gift box
Reset
Order details
Sort by:
Product Title (asc)
Product Title (desc)
Price (low to high)
Price (high to low)
Filter by collection:
Accompaniments
All Cheddars
All Creamery Dairy
All Gift Boxes
Cheese & Meat
Cheese Balls
Cheese Only
Clothing
Corporate Gifting
Crackers
Creamery Cheddars
Creamery Products
Curds
-
$6.00
+
Wicked Minis™ Seasoned Oyster Crackers Garden Dill
-
$6.00
+
Wicked Minis™ Seasoned Oyster Crackers Crushed Red Pepper
-
$8.00
+
Wicked Mix® Smoky Hot Chipotle
-
$8.00
+
Wicked Mix® Chocolate-Laced
-
$8.00
+
Wicked Mix® Spicy Original
-
$10.00
+
Outsiders Kitchen Berries + Cream Pretzel Bites
-
$10.00
+
Outsiders Kitchen Lemon + Poppy Pretzel Bites
-
$10.00
+
Outsiders Kitchen Coffee + Cream Pretzel Bites
-
$10.00
+
Outsiders Kitchen Sugar + Spice Pretzel Bites
-
$12.00
+
Uncle Hoss’s Crisscross Crunch Toffee Crunch
-
$12.00
+
Uncle Hoss’s Crisscross Crunch Salted Caramel Crunch
-
$12.00
+
Uncle Hoss’s Crisscross Crunch Peanut Butter Crunch
-
$12.00
+
Uncle Hoss’s Crisscross Crunch Death by Chocolate Crunch
-
$5.00
+
Cox Honeyland Pure Honey in Glass Skep Jar
Choose a Size...
12 ounces - $12.50
3 ounces - $5.00
X
-
$5.00
+
Cox Honeyland Creamed Honey in Glass Skep Jar
Choose a Size...
12 ounces - $12.50
3 ounces - $5.00
X
-
$13.00
+
Creminelli Fine Meats® Whiskey Uncured Italian Salami - Whiskey
Sold Out
Creminelli Fine Meats® Piccante Uncured Italian Salami - Piccante
-
$11.00
+
Creminelli Fine Meats® Sopressata Uncured Italian Salami - Sopressata
-
$9.00
+
Mimi's Country Candies Buttered Pretzel Caramels - 6 pieces
Sold Out
Mimi's Country Candies Toffee Caramels
-
$9.00
+
Mimi's Country Candies Smoked Bacon Caramels
Sold Out
Gossner Foods® Swiss Cheese
-
$11.00
+
Gossner Foods® Sliced Provolone Cheese
-
$11.00
+
Gossner Foods® Sliced Muenster Cheese
-
$11.00
+
Gossner Foods® Sliced Hot Pepper Cheese
-
$12.50
+
Gossner Foods® Sharp Cheddar Cheese
-
$10.00
+
Gossner Foods® High Mountain Sliced Swiss Cheese
-
$30.00
+
Runamok® Maple Sparkle Syrup®
-
$25.00
+
Runamok® Maple Holiday Spiced Infused Maple Syrup
-
$25.00
+
Runamok® Maple Apple Brandy Barrel-Aged Maple Syrup
-
$14.00
+
Verweij 100% Butter Stroopwafels
-
$8.00
+
De Ruiter Banket Speculaas
-
$9.00
+
Van Den Berg Krakelingen
Sold Out
Carr’s Cheese Melts
-
$6.00
+
Patisserie Aviateur Almond Fingers
-
$6.00
+
Patisserie Aviateur Almond Rounds
-
$18.00
+
Bluebird Candy Company Candied Pecans
-
$16.00
+
Bluebird Candy Company Candied Cashews
-
$8.50
+
Rustic Bakery Artisan Crisps
Choose a Flavor...
Apricot, Pistachio & Brandy - $8.50
Citrus, Ginger & Thyme - $8.50
Tart Cherry, Cacao Nib & Almond - $8.50
X
-
$9.00
+
Mimi's Country Candies Pecan Caramels
Choose a Size...
6 pieces - $9.00
Sold Out - 1 pound - $26.00
X
-
$9.00
+
Mimi's Country Candies Creamy Caramels
Choose a Size...
6 pieces - $9.00
Sold Out - 1 pound - $26.00
X
-
$9.00
+
Mimi's Country Candies Sea Salt Caramels
Choose a Size...
6 pieces - $9.00
Sold Out - 1 pound - $26.00
X
-
$9.00
+
Rustic Bakery Organic Sourdough Flatbread
Choose a Flavor...
Everything Spice - $9.00
Olive Oil & Sel Gris - $9.00
Rosemary and Olive Oil - $9.00
Sweet Onion & Creme Fraiche - $9.00
X
-
$7.00
+
Rustic Bakery Organic Sourdough Flatbread Bites
Choose a Flavor...
Everything Spice - $7.00
Olive Oil & Sel Gris - $7.00
Rosemary & Olive Oil - $7.00
X
-
$7.00
+
Rustic Bakery Vanilla Shortbread
-
$7.00
+
Rustic Bakery Pecan Shortbread
-
$7.00
+
Rustic Bakery Meyer Lemon Shortbread
-
$7.00
+
Rustic Bakery Chocolate Cacao Nib Shortbread
-
$9.00
+
Pepperlane Warm & Fuzzy Peach Jalapeño Preserves
-
$25.00
+
Runamok® Maple Strawberry Rose Infused Maple Syrup
-
$9.00
+
Pepperlane The “Original” Jalapeño Preserves
-
$9.00
+
Pepperlane Sweet Heat Jalapeño Preserves
-
$9.00
+
Pepperlane Raz-Pepper Jalapeño Preserves
-
$9.00
+
Pepperlane Peppers In Pineapple Paradise Jalapeño Preserve
-
$9.00
+
Pepperlane Pepp’ricot Jalapeño Preserves
-
$9.00
+
Pepperlane Meyer, Meyer Lemon on “Fire” Jalapeño Preserves
-
$9.00
+
Pepperlane Sneaky Hippie Mango Django Jazz Jalapeño Preserves
-
$9.00
+
Pepperlane Hot Blooded Orange Jalapeño Preserves
-
$9.00
+
Pepperlane Don’t Take This “Pom” For “Granate” Jalapeño Preserves
-
$9.00
+
Pepperlane Cran-Peño Jalapeño Preserves
Sold Out
Pepperlane Blackberry “Buzz” Jalapeño Preserves
-
$9.00
+
Pepperlane Cherry Bomb Jalapeño Preserves
-
$12.00
+
Mimi's Country Candies Chunk Fudge
Choose a Flavor...
Original - $12.00
Sold Out - Walnuts - $12.00
Sold Out - Peanut Butter - $12.00
Salted Caramel - $12.00
X
-
$9.00
+
Mimi's Country Candies Walnut Caramels
Choose a Size...
6 pieces - $9.00
1 pound - $26.00
X
-
$5.10
+
Mike's Hot Honey®
Choose a Size...
1.88 ounce - $5.10
12 ounce - $15.00
X
-
$8.00
+
Memaw’s Country Kitchen Chocolate Chip Cookies
-
$13.00
+
Bluebird Candy Company Candied Almonds
-
$25.00
+
Runamok® Maple Whiskey Barrel-Aged Maple Syrup
-
$25.00
+
Runamok® Maple Sugarmaker's Cut® Maple Syrup
-
$25.00
+
Runamok® Maple Smoked with Pecan Wood Maple Syrup
-
$25.00
+
Runamok® Maple Rum Barrel-Aged Maple Syrup
-
$25.00
+
Runamok® Maple Merquén Infused Smoked Chili Pepper Maple Syrup
-
$25.00
+
Runamok® Maple Jasmine Tea Infused Maple Syrup
-
$30.00
+
Runamok® Maple Ice Cream Pairing Collection
-
$25.00
+
Runamok® Maple Elderberry Infused Maple Syrup
-
$25.00
+
Runamok® Maple Coffee Infused Maple Syrup
-
$25.00
+
Runamok® Maple Cocoa Bean Infused Maple Syrup
-
$25.00
+
Runamok® Maple Cinnamon + Vanilla Infused Maple Syrup
-
$30.00
+
Runamok® Maple Cheese Pairing Collection
-
$25.00
+
Runamok® Maple Bourbon Barrel-Aged Maple Syrup
-
$8.00
+
Memaw’s Country Kitchen Lemon Coolers
-
$8.00
+
Memaw’s Country Kitchen Cheese Tiddies
-
$8.00
+
Bluebird Candy Company Popcorn
Choose a Flavor...
Caramel & Peanuts - $8.00
Toffee & Almonds - $8.00
White Chocolate - $8.00
X
-
$21.00
+
Bluebird Candy Company Assorted Chocolates Box
Choose a Size...
8 ounces - $21.00
1 pound - $34.00
X
Back
Next
Complete
Add:
We are building your box.
This may take a few seconds...
0
